About My Opinionated Blog

My photo
Welcome to my opinionated blog. I usually only write here when I am seriously grumpy about something, which luckily doesn't happen very often. Sometimes I go back and read an old blog post and wonder how I could have been so upset that I actually bothered blogging about it. But at least I usually agree with what I wrote (otherwise I delete the post). I write in Swedish or English, depending on the subject. Välkommen till min sura åsiktsblogg! Här skriver jag oftast enbart när jag är väldigt förbannad på nånting som just hänt, vilket som tur är händer väldigt sällan. Då och då brukar jag gå tillbaks och läsa nån gammal bloggartikel och förundras hur jag kunde reta upp mig så mycket att jag till och med orkade skriva om det. Däremot brukar jag hålla med mig själv i efterhand eller så raderar jag inlägget. Beroende på ämnet eller källan till min surhet så skriver jag på svenska eller engelska.

Friday, December 3, 2010

On Comcast and internet regulations

The US has a weird mix of complete and healthy competition on consumer merchandize on one hand.  On the other hand we have virtually no competition at all in other areas, for example infrastructure.


The situation when it comes to the lack of competition in infrastructure lands just where complete socialism overlaps with wild west capitalism. 


Try to find an alternative water company or school bus company and folks will think you are strange. Same with power, gas or trash removal, services where there is very healthy competition in most countries. This is a result of local monopolies owning the underlying structures (water pipes, power lines..) as opposed to having the government, federal or local, owning them and opening up for true competition for the services. Another example is the postal service. The USPS has the monopoly on delivering to your letterbox, even though you purchased it yourself. Any non-US readers probably cannot believe this! As a result, no company can compete for cheap envelope delivery since it will require either that you get everyone to purchase separate letterboxes. Fedex and UPS can therefore only compete in higher end door delivery services.  Bizarre!


There is a very similar with cable TV and internet service. In the name of the unregulated business, the service providers here own more than just the cable decoders and  the internet modem, but also all underground wiring often in areas where it is impossible to get permits to dig in more cable. 


Competition is key and lack of it leads to inefficiency regardless of who hold the monopoly. As a result we have among the worst infrastructure and costs are higher and this is especially true for IT services.  In most areas there is only one or two providers and they charge a lot for very little.  Again, in most areas it is even impossible to find a company that can install fiber optics. 


The FCC needs to step in here, not to prevent free competition, but to ensure that there are fair rules and a vibrant healthy market place for these services. What Comcast is doing now is very scary.


What we need is more than that. We need the airport-style system to penetrate the infrastructure sector.  This is where the government owns and controls the basic, raw, underlying, low-profit, infrastructure.  Tax money can be used to fund infrastructure investments because the costs can be recuperated from the companies that provide the upper, high-profit layer. These companies will then lease the fiber lines just as is done today for cell phone frequency bands, air traffic rights and roads.  We will then finally get a modern internet infrastructure at reasonable costs which in turn will open up further business opportunities which is good for job creations, tax money returns and the consumers.

No comments:

Post a Comment