Two facts:
1. A killer is not innocent because he did not kill during 364 days last year. Even spending as little as 5 seconds killing during a period of 25 years still makes him a killer.
2. Coffee spiked with a lethal dose of poison does not get less toxic just because it also contains a spoonful of sugar.
Nobody doubts that AZ has a problem with immigration. And as in all bills most things in the new immigration bill SB1070 are fine and pretty much common sense that most people can agree with. But there are also a few things that may look like details but make the largest impact. Some sections are very problematic, mainly due to ambiguous wording that can (and probably will) be abused by individual police officers. For example, " Section E. A LAW ENFORCEMENT OFFICER, WITHOUT A WARRANT, MAY ARREST A PERSON IF THE OFFICER HAS PROBABLE CAUSE TO BELIEVE THAT THE PERSON HAS COMMITTED ANY PUBLIC OFFENSE THAT MAKES THE PERSON REMOVABLE FROM THE UNITED STATES.". The Public Offense that is referred to is illegal immigration. Think for a moment, what does "probable cause to believe" mean in reality? What does it mean when a sued officer testifies in court or in front of an internal investigation? How can one not have probably cause to believe that a Mexican seen painting a fence could possibly be here illegally? Or what about the dude that just paid his $240 groceries with cash ten minutes ago? OK, so this would merely mean that only people here illegally would be arrested, right? Or would it...?
A real life situation could be a Mexican looking US citizen walking on the street. A police officer identifies her as Mexican looking and possibly suspected illegal immigrant (for any perfectly plausible reason) which is a public offense of the type in section E, above. He therefore, rightfully, asks her for her immigration documents and she rightfully replies friendly that she is a US citizen. This is of course the same answer any illegal immigrant would give. The officer, again must choose to take her word for it or not, and this particular time he decides not to take her word for it and, correctly, arrests her. She did nothing wrong and he did nothing wrong according to this bill either. Everything makes sense according to the bill and a US citizen is now in the police station. She would obviously be released as soon as someone brings her citizenship documents to the police station which would not take more than a few hours. But as a consequence, the next time she leaves her house she will surely carry her driving license with her and so will all her friends that look like her. The paradox is that since nobody can tell a citizen apart from a legal or illegal immigrant everyone will in fact be required to carry documents unless they are prepared to be arrested if they don't. The effect will be that you'd better bring it just in case, so you can prove that you are legal. You have nothing to fear as long as you are innocent and can prove it on the spot.
Another example, a lawful immigrant (such as me) decides that he does not dare to carry his J-1 visa documentation with him while on the beach. After all, it would require that he brought his passport with visa stamps and also one original US letters with stamps from the US embassy in his home country and one document stamped by his employer certifying that his employment status is in good standing, renewed every 6 months. These papers, as all immigrants know, are virtually impossible to replace and nobody carries them around. Losing a J-1 visa for example means having to leave the country within 30 days, get a new passport, obtain documents from the employer while abroad, book an interview at the US embassy, and risk a long background check if you happen to be a virologist. In any case it would probably take 4-6 months to get back in which would mean losing the job, which in turn would mean not being able to get back in at all, which would mean losing car and home and life as you knew it. I kept all my docs in a safe and would never want to carry them around wearing shorts. Anyway, section 3-A-2 in the bill states that he can now be charged for trespassing (fine is no less than $500 the first offense) if he does not carry documents according to 1304(e). So it is now any police officer's duty to check that. If this person gets told by an officer to produce his papers he would and should be a) arrested on the spot without warrant, b) subjected to 8-Sec 1373 c which means detained waiting for federal USCIS to arrive and investigate, which would presumably not happen that same day. To make voters calm the bill states "Section J. THIS SECTION SHALL BE IMPLEMENTED IN A MANNER CONSISTENT WITH FEDERAL LAWS REGULATING IMMIGRATION, PROTECTING THE CIVIL RIGHTS OF ALL PERSONS AND RESPECTING THE PRIVILEGES AND IMMUNITIES OF UNITED STATES CITIZENS." This section is of course bullshit since these constitutional rights by definition apply to any section of any bill whatsoever apart from possibly the Patriot Act. But note that this section J specifically does not mention any civil rights of non-citizens including legal immigrants like myself. And, again, how does Officer B know that the guy's friend on the beach is or isn't a citizen?
We can assume that the absolute majority of all police officers would be reasonable and decide not to take the issue that far, we all think that "I am a nice guy and have nothing to fear, they would never do that", but there is nothing that would restrict it other than the officer's own judgement. The wording is ambiguous enough to raise concerns (lots of "reasonable suspicion" etc which means nothing if not defined). And as stated already under A in the bill, they are in fact encouraged to max out on their actions : "NO OFFICIAL OR AGENCY OF THIS STATE OR A COUNTY, CITY, TOWN ... OF THIS STATE MAY ADOPT A POLICY THAT LIMITS OR RESTRICTS THE ENFORCEMENT OF FEDERAL IMMIGRATION LAWS TO LESS THAN THE FULL EXTENT PERMITTED BY FEDERAL LAW.". The bill even specifies the fine, $1-5k per day, for any officer who does not act or implement policy "to the full extent permitted".
I get scared every time I hear sentences like "if you haven't done anything wrong you have nothing to fear", because such practices tend to put the burden of proof on to the citizen. I cannot see how this law could be implemented in the spirit of the constitution. 20 years ago, there was a widely accepted boycott of Arizona because they refused to recognize MLK day. This bill does not help them to recover from that embarrassment.

